
Negotiated resolutions, and not just courtroom victories.
That’s what Attorney General Wilfred Abrahams yesterday told the House of Assembly was needed in Barbados, as he introduced the Supreme Court Of Judicature (Amendment) (No. 2) Bill, which is designed to clear a long-standing bottleneck in the Court of Appeal.”
The Bill responds to a conflict between the parent Act and the court’s own rules.
Abrahams said the Law Reform Commission, headed by former Attorney General and Chief Justice Sir David Simmons, flagged the problem. The Civil Procedure Rules, introduced around 2008, allow a single Court of Appeal judge to hear applications for leave to appeal. The Supreme Court Of Judicature Act,however, reserved such powers for a panel of three judges.
He said the commission took the view that subordinate legislation, such as court rules, could not override or extend the powers conferred by the Parent Act. The anomaly was never corrected when the rules took effect, and it had contributed to the backlog of appeals.
Leave to appeal is not an appeal itself, he explained, but a request for permission to bring one. Requiring three judges to hear it was impractical.
“Where you have to get effectively the full court to hear an application for leave to appeal to itself, it is almost a nonsense,” he told MPs.
Under the amendment, a single judge may hear applications for leave and other administrative or procedural matters tied to an appeal. Where a judge is minded to grant leave, he or she may do so alone. Where a judge is inclined to refuse, the parties must be heard. Abrahams said this meant there was “no real prejudice to the individual person”.
Limits
He stressed the limits of the change.
“This amendment does not allow a single judge of the Court of Appeal to hear appeals or to deal with the substantive matter that is actually being sought to be appealed,” he said.
A replacement provision makes clear that, subject to the single-judge provision, every appeal or reference to the Court of Appeal may only be heard by three judges and decided by majority opinion.
The country’s senior legal advisor said the commission had also suggested writing the rules’ appeal procedures into the Act itself, but that created cross-referencing problems. The Act and the rules will therefore be read together for now, with a comprehensive overhaul to come. He said the current fix could not wait for that review.
“It is simply a matter of making wrong things right,” he said.
Abrahams said the reform was one part of a broader push to reduce backlogs in both civil and criminal matters, and that law alone would not solve them. The veteran attorney said Barbadians often resisted settling disputes.
“Most Barbadians, Sir, want their day in court and people will say that to you,” he said. He recalled advising clients that an offer of 80 now might be worth more than a possible 100 after a decade of litigation. Many, he said, still insisted on “all or nothing”.
He traced the justice system’s gradual shift from the old adversarial model, in which litigation was “like a boxing match”, to one that encourages compromise and looks at the substance of a claim rather than its form. Further progress, he argued, required a change in public attitudes.
“We require a culture shift to bring down the backlog in the civil matters,” he said.
That shift, he added, meant accepting that the goal was not total victory.
“It is not a must-win at all costs,” he said, adding that the aim should be a resolution, after which both sides could walk away feeling that justice was served. (BA)
The post Amendments should help clear backlog, says Abrahams appeared first on nationnews.com.